3rd Circuit Court
of Appeal
Press Release
Opinions Rendered
From 02/27/08 To 02/27/08
Opinions written
by: Hon. Ulysses Gene Thibodeaux
STEPHEN SCULL
THOMSON
VERSUS
LILY MARIE
STEEL THOMSON
Date Filed:
Trial Court:
Fifteenth Judicial District Court
Trial Court
Number: 20040128
Trial Judge: Hon.
David Blanchet
Opinion
Rendered on:
The Opinion was
Published
The Opinion -
Amended and, as Amended, Affirmed.
Opinion
Panel:
Hon.
Ulysses Gene Thibodeaux - Writing
Hon.
Sylvia R. Cooks - Dissents in Part
Remarks:
and assigns written reasons.
Hon.
Jimmie C. Peters
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MELANCON
EQUIPMENT, INC.
VERSUS
NATIONAL RENTAL
CO., LTD.
Date Filed:
Trial Court:
Trial Court
Number: 2005CV01946
Trial Judge: Hon.
Frances Moran Bouillion
Opinion
Rendered on:
The Opinion was
Published
The Opinion -
Amended and, as Amended, Affirmed.
Opinion
Panel:
Hon.
Ulysses Gene Thibodeaux - Writing
Hon.
Sylvia R. Cooks
Hon.
Jimmie C. Peters
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MACLAFF, INC.
ET AL.
VERSUS
ARCH INS. CO.,
ET AL.
Date Filed:
Trial Court:
Fifteenth Judicial District Court
Trial Court
Number: 20031039
Trial Judge: Hon.
Marilyn Carr Castle
Opinion
Rendered on:
The Opinion was
Published
The Opinion -
Affirmed
Opinion
Panel:
Hon.
Ulysses Gene Thibodeaux - Writing
Hon.
Sylvia R. Cooks
Hon.
Jimmie C. Peters - Dissents
Opinion
Remarks: PETERS, J., DISSENTS, FINDING THAT THERE
EXISTS GENUINE
ISSUES OF MATERIAL FACT REQUIRING A TRIAL ON
THE
MERITS.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Opinions written
by: Hon. John D. Saunders
DR. CLARK
GUNDERSON, ET AL.
VERSUS
F. A. RICHARD
& ASSOCIATES, INC., ET AL.
Lead
Date Filed:
Trial Court:
Fourteenth Judicial District Court
Trial Court
Number: 2004-2417
Trial Judge: Hon.
Opinion
Rendered on:
The Opinion was
Published
The Opinion -
Affirmed
Opinion
Panel:
Hon. John
D. Saunders - Writing
Hon.
Jimmie C. Peters - Concurs
Hon. Glenn
B. Gremillion - Concurs
Opinion
Remarks: WRITS DENIED; AFFIRMED.
Peters, J.,
concurs in the result and assigns additional
reasons.
Gremillion, J., concurs in the results for
the reasons
assigned by
Judge Peters in his concurring opinion.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CLARK A.
GUNDERSON, M.D., ET AL
VERSUS
F. A. RICHARD
& ASSOCIATES, INC.,
ET AL
Lead
Date Filed:
Trial Court:
Fourteenth Judicial District Court
Trial Court Number: 2004-002417
Trial Judge: Hon.
Opinion
Rendered on:
The Opinion was
Published
The Opinion -
Writ Denied
Opinion
Panel:
Hon. John
D. Saunders - Writing
Hon.
Jimmie C. Peters - Concurs
Hon. Glenn
B. Gremillion - Concurs
Opinion
Remarks: WRITS DENIED; AFFIRMED.
Peters, J.,
concurs in the result and assigns additional
reasons.
Gremillion, J.,
concurs in the results for the reasons
assigned by
Judge Peters in his concurring opinion.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CLARK A.
GUNDERSON, M.D., ET AL
VERSUS
F. A. RICHARD
& ASSOCIATES, INC.,
ET AL
Lead
Date Filed:
Trial Court:
Fourteenth Judicial District Court
Trial Court
Number: 2004-002417
Trial Judge: Hon.
Opinion
Rendered on:
The Opinion was
Published
The Opinion -
Writ Denied
Opinion
Panel:
Hon. John
D. Saunders - Writing
Hon.
Jimmie C. Peters - Concurs
Hon. Glenn
B. Gremillion - Concurs
Opinion
Remarks: WRITS DENIED; AFFIRMED.
Peters, J.,
concurs in the result and assigns additional
reasons.
Gremillion, J.,
concurs in the results for the reasons
assigned by
Judge Peters in his concurring opinion.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Opinions written
by: Hon. Billy Howard Ezell
SANDRA KAY
BERGSTEDT, ET AL.
VERSUS
LOUISIANA FARM
BUREAU INS. CO., ET AL.
Date Filed:
Trial Court:
Fourteenth Judicial District Court
Trial Court
Number: 2005-1525
Trial Judge: Hon.
Arthur J. Planchard
Opinion
Rendered on:
The Opinion was
not Published
The Opinion -
Affirmed in Part, Reversed in Part and Remanded
Opinion
Panel:
Hon. John
D. Saunders
Hon. Marc
T. Amy
Hon. Billy
Howard Ezell - Writing
Opinion
Remarks: Affirmed in Part, as Amended; Reversed in
Part; and
Remanded.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Opinions written
by: Hon. J. David Painter
STATE OF
VERSUS
GARY
LAFLEUR
Date Filed:
Trial Court: ST. LANDRY
Twenty-Seventh Judicial District Court
Trial Court
Number: 04-K-5581-C
Trial Judge: Hon.
Alonzo Harris
Opinion
Rendered on:
The Opinion was
not Published
The Opinion -
Affirmed
Opinion
Panel:
Hon. Glenn
B. Gremillion
Hon.
Elizabeth A. Pickett
Hon. J.
David Painter - Writing
Total Civil
Cases 7
Civil PC
Opinions 0
Civil PC
Publish 0
Civil PC Not
Publish 0
Civil Majority
Opinions 7
Civil
Majority Publish 6
Civil
Majority Not Publish 1
Civil Opinion
on Motions 0
Civil Summary
Dispositions 0
Total Criminal
Cases 1
Criminal PC
Opinions 0
Criminal PC
Publish 0
Criminal PC
Not Publish 0
Criminal
Majority Opinions 1
Criminal Majority
Publish 0
Criminal
Majority Not Publish 1
Criminal
Opinion on Motions 0
Criminal
Summary Dispositions 0
Total Juvenile
Cases 0
Juvenile PC
Opinions 0
Juvenile PC
Publish 0
Juvenile PC
Not Publish 0
Juvenile
Majority Opinions 0
Juvenile
Majority Publish 0
Juvenile
Majority Not Publish 0
Juvenile
Opinion on Motions 0
Juvenile Summary Dispositions 0
Total Workers Comp
Cases 0
Workers Comp PC
Opinions 0
Workers Comp
PC Publish 0
Workers Comp
PC Not Publish 0
Workers Comp
Majority Opinions 0
Workers Comp
Majority Publish 0
Workers Comp
Majority Not Publish 0
Workers Comp
Opinion on Motions 0
Workers Comp
Summary Dispositions 0
------------------------------------------------
Miscellaneous Totals
Total Consolidated
Cases 3
Total Opinion on
Writ Grants 2
Total Opinion on
Remands 0
Total Dismissed
Appeals 0
Total Joint
Motions to Dismiss Appeal 0
Total Dismiss by
Court Order 0
Total Civil
Motions 0
Total Criminal Motions 0